I always say what's hardest on the parent is probably going to be the best thing for the child. In my experience, that is nearly always the case. It is much easier to just give them what they want than to fight them when you're in "that moment"! One of my most embarrassing moments as a parent tested his theory that I had preached for years, even prior to having children. I had to swallow a lot of crow, let me tell you! But low and behold, my theory proved true!
It was my 34th birthday, and my entire family of around 15 or so met at Olive Garden for dinner. My husband and I went early to get a table. My 4 year old son was always fairly patient, but I knew when they told us the wait would be nearly an hour that my 15 month old would not fare so well. He was our future president/billionaire/prizefighter/dictator...we weren't really sure yet which direction it might go, but we knew it would definitely "go"!
Needless to say, waiting was not his strongest attribute. After climbing around in the rocks outside for a while, and then being held like a captured alligator by his dad in the lobby for a few minutes, we were finally called to our table. We were seated, and the waiter promptly handed our little prince a pack of crayons and a coloring menu. His reaction? Just as one would expect a future president/billionaire/prizefighter/dictator would react! Like a rabid monkey on steroids!! He proceeded to swipe not only the menu and crayons off the table, but he swiped EVERYTHING off that was within an arm's radius! Dave and I were frantically trying to grab stuff and get control of the situation as our son began pushing against the table in an attempt to overturn the highchair. He was screaming as though he was on fire!
Because we had been having problems with this type thing for a few weeks prior to this event, we had started to realize our son seemed to be more into controlling us than enjoying his freedom from the high chair. It seemed like everything had become a power struggle, and we had determined we had to show him we were in control. The way we looked at it, if he began controlling us at less than 2 years old, we would have a huge problem when he became a teen.
So, I made the brave decision of looking him square in the eye and saying, "Cry all you want, it won't do you any good, because you are not getting out of that high chair until we are ready to leave." Well, all systems were go from there!! He amped up a few more decibels! The wait staff began gathering in the corridor, whispering and staring at us. They quit seating anyone near us.
My father-in-law suggested we pull him out of the seat and “bust his behind”, which I am not opposed to spanking, but at this point with all the audience we had, I was sure someone would accuse us of child abuse if we actually spanked him in public! The icing on the cake was when a very pretentious middle aged woman from the other side of the restaurant came over and said, "Excuse me, is your child ok? Because I could hear him crying from all the way over there and I though maybe he was sick or something and you just weren't doing anything about it." I calmly assured her that he was fine, that it was just an old fashioned temper tantrum, and we'd soon be on our way. We got our food, crammed it down and got out of there as soon as we could. I could feel the silent applause as we walked out. It was many months before I could go back!
We only had one more episode of "restaurant violence" after the big Olive Garden event of 2000, and it was exactly 1 week later. This time we were in Wright's Cafeteria and were in a private room with a partition between us and an empty room next door. As soon as we put our son in the highchair, he once again started the "I'm on fire, help me!!!" scream. I told him if he started that again he couldn't stay in the room with us (the whole family, this time about 20), and he would have to go into the other room alone. He continued screaming, so I rolled the chair to the room that adjoined our room, made sure the wheels were locked and he was safely strapped in and was not able to push against anything, and I pulled the curtain just enough where I could still see him but he couldn't see us. He fell completely silent. I waited about 15 minutes and opened the curtain and smiled at him. I praised him for being so sweet and invited him over to our side, and he started crying again as if he suddenly remembered he was supposed to still be just as livid that I expected him to actually sit like a gentleman! I re-closed the curtain, finished eating and left him until we were done. From that day on we never had another problem in a restaurant again!
As awful as the Olive Garden night was, it clearly drew a line in the sand for us. Mom and Dad are not weak!! Even though it may have looked that way from the Olive Garden side, we were only concerned how it was being perceived by our child. If he had gotten out of that high chair, even for a spanking, he would have won. His goal was to get out! That's all that mattered. For the strong willed, that pop on the behind, or time out, or whatever you can threaten is worth the win for them getting what they want at any cost! It is all about the win!
Would it have been easier for us to let him out of the highchair so everyone could eat in peace and we could have not have been embarrassed? Yes! Better for him? NO!! Absolutely not!
Deuteronomy 6:1 and 2 says, "These are the commands, decrees and laws the Lord your God directed me to teach you to observe in the land that you are crossing the Jordan to possess, so that you, your children and their children after them may fear the Lord your God as long as you live by keeping all his decrees and commands that I give you, and so that you may enjoy long life." When we have a firm hold on our kids now, they will have a less-stressful life later.
Another aspect of firm parenting is that your children will see you as truthful. If you throw out meaningless threats when they are little, what makes you think they'll believe you when you talk about the consequences of drugs or sex when they're teens? Meaning what you say now is establishing a foundation of trust between you and your child that will last a lifetime! It takes a lot more wherewithal to stand firm and be parents who are in the driver's seat than it does to give your little bundles of joy the reins. It's tough. It's tiring. It's much harder on you...which usually means it's what's best for them.
On a side note, our little president/billionaire/prizefighter/dictator has grown into an outstanding young man who worked hard and graduated high school a semester early, and he has become the youngest manager his employer has ever promoted. He rents his own apartment, pays his own bills and works harder than most anyone I know. He is not afraid to face the unknown and he is confident in the face of a challenge! We are proud that he has used his strong will and determination for good and are excited to see how God will use him along his path to success!
Hang in there, parents of the strong willed! Don't be afraid to stand firmly in the hurricane and being his or her anchor, no matter how big the waves may be. One day they will make you proud, and it'll all be worth it!